The player is loading ...
93 | Fiber Fundamentals: Soluble vs Insoluble and the Gut Microbiome

Let's talk about dietary fiber in plain terms: the difference between soluble (fermentable) and insoluble fibers, how soluble fiber feeds gut microbes to produce beneficial short-chain fatty acids, and why insoluble fiber adds bulk to ease transit. We'll also briefly discuss how FOS/GOS and inulin fit into the picture. 

Practical takeaways include aiming for about 25–30+ g/day from whole plant foods, using psyllium as a balanced supplement option, increasing fiber slowly to avoid discomfort, and seeking specialized care for those with GI conditions, since more fiber isn't appropriate for everyone.

Resources

 

Thanks for listening.

I'd love to hear from you. Leave me a voicemail with feedback or submit a question (click the pink "Send Camille a Message" button on the side of the page) 💚

Camille's Helpful Links for Practitioners

00:04 - Introduction to Gut Health

00:34 - Understanding Fiber and Its Importance

04:35 - Soluble vs. Insoluble Fiber

09:08 - Gradually Increasing Fiber Intake

10:31 - Special Considerations for Fiber Supplementation

11:45 - Upcoming Supplement Deep Dive Course

WEBVTT

00:00:00.017 --> 00:00:03.997
Hi there. Welcome to In the Clinic with Camille. My name is Camille Freeman.

00:00:04.217 --> 00:00:05.657
I'm an herbalist and nutritionist.

00:00:05.917 --> 00:00:10.017
And in this podcast, I share little tips and tidbits that might be helpful for other practitioners.

00:00:10.737 --> 00:00:15.697
So earlier this week, I taught a class about the gut-brain-nervous system connection

00:00:15.697 --> 00:00:17.877
and non-nutritive sweeteners.

00:00:18.357 --> 00:00:22.437
And we had a lot of questions towards the end of the class. And I realized after

00:00:22.437 --> 00:00:27.237
the question and answer session ended that a couple of people had put in the

00:00:27.237 --> 00:00:29.637
chat some questions about fiber

00:00:29.637 --> 00:00:33.717
and what types of fiber specifically are supportive of the gut microbiome.

00:00:34.037 --> 00:00:38.617
So I thought I would answer that question here for folks who maybe didn't get

00:00:38.617 --> 00:00:43.057
to come to the class but are still interested in this topic and just to supplement the class itself.

00:00:43.237 --> 00:00:48.897
So let's just talk about fiber very briefly. Now, this is just a very short synopsis.

00:00:48.997 --> 00:00:52.837
This is a nuanced topic. I could probably do a whole class for an hour and a

00:00:52.837 --> 00:00:55.697
half on fiber, and maybe I will sometime. I don't know if you're interested.

00:00:55.897 --> 00:01:01.757
Let me know. But for right now, I just want to go over some bird's eye view, big picture things.

00:01:02.237 --> 00:01:06.737
All right, so what is dietary fiber? Dietary fiber is carbohydrates and lignans,

00:01:06.817 --> 00:01:11.157
but mostly carbohydrates that do not get digested in the stomach and small intestine

00:01:11.157 --> 00:01:14.017
and that make their way into the colon.

00:01:14.237 --> 00:01:18.597
These typically come from plants, And as you probably know, carbohydrates are

00:01:18.597 --> 00:01:23.037
just long chains of individual sugar molecules stuck together.

00:01:23.437 --> 00:01:27.757
Okay, so the recommendation for adult humans is that we get,

00:01:27.917 --> 00:01:32.837
depending on who you're asking, somewhere in the 20 to 35 or more grams per day.

00:01:33.317 --> 00:01:36.497
Most Americans are getting substantially less than that.

00:01:36.657 --> 00:01:41.037
I believe the average is something in the 12 to 15 grams per day range,

00:01:41.037 --> 00:01:43.877
and a lot of people are getting much less than that.

00:01:44.636 --> 00:01:49.256
One of the things that muddies the waters a little bit when it comes to fiber

00:01:49.256 --> 00:01:51.296
is soluble versus insoluble.

00:01:51.576 --> 00:01:56.956
And this is a little unfortunate because it's based on the chemistry of the

00:01:56.956 --> 00:02:01.316
fibers, but I think it just confuses people when they're thinking about fiber,

00:02:01.396 --> 00:02:04.256
and it makes it a little bit more complex than it has to be.

00:02:04.576 --> 00:02:08.676
So soluble fiber is fiber that dissolves in water.

00:02:08.936 --> 00:02:13.196
This means it has a viscous feel to it, generally speaking.

00:02:13.196 --> 00:02:16.456
This includes things like pectins and gums you're

00:02:16.456 --> 00:02:20.096
going to find this type of fiber in oats beans

00:02:20.096 --> 00:02:24.456
apples citrus fruits a lot of things like that and the reason that they dissolve

00:02:24.456 --> 00:02:27.596
in the water is that they have these they're these long chains of carbohydrates

00:02:27.596 --> 00:02:31.596
but instead of being one big straight chain it's a bunch of branching chains

00:02:31.596 --> 00:02:36.456
off of sort of a central one and they have groups on the end that are hydrophilic

00:02:36.456 --> 00:02:39.676
meaning they're water loving so they form kind of a slime a little bit.

00:02:40.176 --> 00:02:43.796
All right, so that's soluble. And you can think about it. They're soluble, they dissolve in water.

00:02:44.556 --> 00:02:50.596
Insoluble fibers are not water soluble. They add bulk, they speed to transit.

00:02:50.796 --> 00:02:52.556
This is things like cellulose and lignin.

00:02:53.076 --> 00:02:58.736
And the reason that they add bulk is because they don't dissolve in water, but they absorb water.

00:02:59.196 --> 00:03:03.156
So when the fiber moves through your digestive tract, it's pulling water towards

00:03:03.156 --> 00:03:05.456
it, and it's bulking up the stool.

00:03:05.796 --> 00:03:09.676
Now, this is great. Both of these are great things. We'll talk about why in a moment.

00:03:09.956 --> 00:03:17.716
And most plants or plant foods, plant-based foods, have a mix of both soluble and insoluble.

00:03:17.876 --> 00:03:21.036
So you'll hear like, oh, apples are rich in pectin, which is soluble.

00:03:21.216 --> 00:03:24.636
Yes, it is. That is true. But they also have some insoluble fiber.

00:03:24.776 --> 00:03:28.996
So we can't really categorize foods as soluble or insoluble because,

00:03:29.316 --> 00:03:31.476
like many things, they are complex.

00:03:31.696 --> 00:03:35.956
They have a bunch of constituents. And generally speaking, most of our plant

00:03:35.956 --> 00:03:40.256
foods have some soluble, some insoluble, maybe just more or less of one or the other.

00:03:40.963 --> 00:03:47.423
Okay, so in the colon, the soluble fiber, the type that is viscous and dissolves

00:03:47.423 --> 00:03:49.363
in the water, is fermentable.

00:03:49.523 --> 00:03:54.183
What that means is we can't digest it ourselves in terms of the stomach,

00:03:54.363 --> 00:03:57.103
the small intestine, it's not getting absorbed, and so forth.

00:03:57.223 --> 00:04:02.743
But when it gets down into the colon, where most of our gut flora live,

00:04:03.063 --> 00:04:05.203
they can eat this type of fiber.

00:04:05.583 --> 00:04:10.083
That's what we mean when we say fermentable. That means these gut flora are,

00:04:10.083 --> 00:04:14.263
quote, digesting this fiber, and that's the process of fermentation.

00:04:14.683 --> 00:04:20.043
And when they do that, they produce gases and they produce short-chain fatty acids.

00:04:20.243 --> 00:04:26.263
So when they eat the soluble fiber, they make gas, they make short-chain fatty acids.

00:04:26.643 --> 00:04:31.143
The short-chain fatty acids are quite good for health. The gas can be a little

00:04:31.143 --> 00:04:34.443
bit problematic depending on your tolerance. We'll talk about that in a second.

00:04:35.383 --> 00:04:39.023
Insoluble fiber, the bacteria that live in our gut and the other flora that

00:04:39.023 --> 00:04:44.323
live in the gut, they don't generally have the enzymes that break down the insoluble fiber.

00:04:44.663 --> 00:04:47.683
So they mostly pass through the colon unchanged.

00:04:48.423 --> 00:04:52.663
However, they do have this benefit of providing bulk. So really helpful for

00:04:52.663 --> 00:04:57.003
constipation and that sort of thing, right? Hopefully that makes sense.

00:04:57.163 --> 00:04:58.343
So they both have benefits.

00:04:58.583 --> 00:05:03.523
The soluble fiber are acting as prebiotics. They're feeding the gut flora.

00:05:03.783 --> 00:05:08.303
The insoluble fiber is bulking up the stool, making it easier to pass,

00:05:08.443 --> 00:05:10.983
preventing or treating constipation, and so forth.

00:05:11.523 --> 00:05:16.943
All right, so our soluble fiber has the benefits of doing things like lowering

00:05:16.943 --> 00:05:18.983
cholesterol, stabilizing blood sugar,

00:05:19.463 --> 00:05:24.843
supporting the healthy bacteria and other flora that live in the gut and suppressing

00:05:24.843 --> 00:05:27.723
the potentially pathogenic bacteria that.

00:05:28.801 --> 00:05:33.541
Normalizing immune function, regulating the gut-brain-nervous system axis, and so forth.

00:05:33.621 --> 00:05:38.141
And it does all of that via increasing the amount of short-chain fatty acids.

00:05:38.361 --> 00:05:43.461
So you need the soluble fiber that gets, quote, digested or fermented by the

00:05:43.461 --> 00:05:49.481
gut flora and produces short-chain fatty acids, which then have systemic effects that are helpful.

00:05:49.841 --> 00:05:54.161
They also have local effects that are helpful within the digestive tract themselves. Okay?

00:05:54.801 --> 00:05:59.461
So how do we get fiber? How do we advise clients about getting fiber and that sort of thing?

00:05:59.801 --> 00:06:04.061
Well, first of all, the main thing is just getting plenty of whole plant foods.

00:06:04.201 --> 00:06:08.141
So this would be things like whole grains, nuts, fruits and veggies, that sort of thing.

00:06:08.361 --> 00:06:11.501
It's pretty easy to look at what somebody's eating for a few days and get a

00:06:11.501 --> 00:06:16.381
feel for if they are in the appropriate range of fiber intake or not,

00:06:16.401 --> 00:06:19.021
but it can be helpful to track for a few days.

00:06:19.021 --> 00:06:24.421
If not, I'm really looking for something in the range of 25 to 30 or more grams

00:06:24.421 --> 00:06:26.081
of fiber overall per day.

00:06:26.974 --> 00:06:30.774
If somebody is not able to get that amount of fiber in their diet,

00:06:30.774 --> 00:06:36.154
or for whatever reason, a supplement seems like it might be a better choice,

00:06:36.154 --> 00:06:39.294
a lot of times psyllium is my go-to.

00:06:39.614 --> 00:06:44.094
And the reason that psyllium, I find, is a really optimal choice is because

00:06:44.094 --> 00:06:47.594
it has a mix of soluble and insoluble fiber.

00:06:47.994 --> 00:06:50.994
So it's mostly soluble. And remember,

00:06:51.094 --> 00:06:55.834
the soluble form of fiber is what is feeding the healthy gut flora.

00:06:56.554 --> 00:07:00.274
Okay, so I really like psyllium as a first choice for people.

00:07:00.574 --> 00:07:05.954
If somebody is primarily struggling with constipation, then sometimes you'll

00:07:05.954 --> 00:07:12.174
see supplements like wheat bran or cellulose, etc., that are more insoluble.

00:07:12.594 --> 00:07:17.194
However, I find that even when somebody is having constipation,

00:07:17.534 --> 00:07:21.334
the psyllium is going to provide some insoluble fibers and some bulking.

00:07:21.334 --> 00:07:27.014
So I find that it's a nice, happy medium for both. Now, you have probably heard

00:07:27.014 --> 00:07:35.074
about other types of prebiotics, such as fructooligosaccharides and so forth, inulin, etc.

00:07:35.574 --> 00:07:42.134
These are also constituents of plants, and they are technically considered fiber.

00:07:42.134 --> 00:07:47.694
An oligosaccharide is basically a smaller chain of a bunch of sugars put together.

00:07:47.954 --> 00:07:52.614
So often we wouldn't think of it as a fiber. However, in terms of the action

00:07:52.614 --> 00:07:54.894
in the body, they are counted as fibers.

00:07:55.114 --> 00:07:59.854
So things like FOS, GOS, inulin, these are technically considered fibers.

00:08:00.054 --> 00:08:03.154
They are not broken down in the small intestine. We don't.

00:08:03.910 --> 00:08:07.050
Individually as humans digest them, but when they get into the colon,

00:08:07.270 --> 00:08:09.010
our gut flora can digest them.

00:08:09.310 --> 00:08:13.770
They are fermented just like some of the other fibers we were talking about before.

00:08:14.030 --> 00:08:18.910
Now, the reason that you aren't usually going to see like a fiber powder that's

00:08:18.910 --> 00:08:24.130
entirely made of FOS or inulin is because these types of fibers are,

00:08:24.250 --> 00:08:26.530
because they're shorter and smaller,

00:08:26.810 --> 00:08:30.950
they are fermented or digested by the gut flora very quickly.

00:08:31.250 --> 00:08:37.690
And they therefore produce a high level of gas, which for a lot of people can

00:08:37.690 --> 00:08:40.750
be uncomfortable, can cause some bloating, can cause some discomfort,

00:08:40.950 --> 00:08:42.750
some cramping, and that sort of thing.

00:08:42.930 --> 00:08:47.070
So these ones, while they are technically fibers and they are prebiotics in

00:08:47.070 --> 00:08:52.550
that they are feeding the healthy, beneficial gut flora, we generally do better

00:08:52.550 --> 00:08:54.030
with them in smaller amounts.

00:08:54.190 --> 00:08:57.510
And of course, we have some people, such as those with IBS and other types of

00:08:57.510 --> 00:09:03.330
digestive issues, where they may do better of whitting them mostly or entirely.

00:09:04.710 --> 00:09:07.890
So they're more rapidly fermented, they produce more gas, and so forth.

00:09:08.070 --> 00:09:12.590
So a few last things I'll say to you about fiber is that if somebody is starting

00:09:12.590 --> 00:09:17.250
from a low fiber situation, we want to build up really, really slowly.

00:09:17.750 --> 00:09:22.430
We want to start with just a small increase. We don't want to go immediately

00:09:22.430 --> 00:09:27.050
from 10 grams of fiber a day to 25, because what will happen is that person

00:09:27.050 --> 00:09:30.310
will have cramping, they'll have diarrhea, they will not be happy with you.

00:09:30.530 --> 00:09:36.630
So the recommendation that I provide for you as a practitioner is to gradually increase.

00:09:36.790 --> 00:09:42.250
My standard recommendation is let's add one or two servings of fruits and vegetables

00:09:42.250 --> 00:09:46.830
per day for a few weeks and then slowly go up from there.

00:09:46.870 --> 00:09:50.650
And if you need a supplement, same thing, start with a very small dose of the

00:09:50.650 --> 00:09:54.030
supplement and gradually build up from that point.

00:09:54.836 --> 00:09:58.016
We're not going to get into full contraindications, but I do like to mention

00:09:58.016 --> 00:10:02.736
that there are certain situations where fiber supplementation is not possible

00:10:02.736 --> 00:10:08.716
or not optimal, and perhaps we'll get into that in another podcast episode.

00:10:08.816 --> 00:10:13.136
But for right now, let's just say that these recommendations are for the general

00:10:13.136 --> 00:10:19.496
population who do not have any major digestive-related conditions.

00:10:19.496 --> 00:10:23.816
And if somebody does have something like diverticulitis, diverticulosis,

00:10:23.996 --> 00:10:28.936
any kind of surgery, Crohn's disease, etc., you may need to think more carefully.

00:10:28.936 --> 00:10:31.396
You want to have specialized training, make sure that you know what you're doing.

00:10:31.556 --> 00:10:36.436
This is just for the average person without any serious GI-related symptoms.

00:10:36.868 --> 00:10:42.128
Diagnoses. Okay, so I hope that helps clear up the differences between soluble

00:10:42.128 --> 00:10:47.648
and insoluble fiber and how they may or may not affect the gut flora.

00:10:47.848 --> 00:10:56.248
Just as a recap, soluble fiber serves as food for our healthy, beneficial gut flora.

00:10:56.908 --> 00:11:01.328
Insoluble fiber does not seem to directly impact the gut flora,

00:11:01.328 --> 00:11:06.808
but it does impact digestion by bulking up the stool, making it easier to pass,

00:11:06.968 --> 00:11:11.148
and therefore it probably has indirect effects on the gut flora.

00:11:11.548 --> 00:11:15.048
Okay, I hope that's clear. If you have any questions, let me know.

00:11:15.248 --> 00:11:20.128
And lastly, if you're interested in all this, the ins and outs of supplementation

00:11:20.128 --> 00:11:25.568
and things like that, next year in 2026, I am doing a supplement deep dive.

00:11:25.568 --> 00:11:30.588
This is one continuing education class per month for practitioners.

00:11:31.448 --> 00:11:37.168
You can sign up and get on the wait list if you go to camillefreeman.com slash supplement soon.

00:11:37.768 --> 00:11:40.288
And you can see all the different topics that we're going to be covering.

00:11:40.468 --> 00:11:43.548
You can get on the wait list, which also includes a special discount when the

00:11:43.548 --> 00:11:44.768
course opens in January.

00:11:45.508 --> 00:11:48.948
I'd love to have you there. We're going to do some really interesting topics

00:11:48.948 --> 00:11:53.288
and just learn more about how to advise clients about some of the different

00:11:53.288 --> 00:11:54.468
supplements that are on the market,

00:11:54.688 --> 00:11:59.008
including fad supplements, as well as some of the more standard ones that many

00:11:59.008 --> 00:12:01.328
clients are taking, but maybe not in appropriate doses,

00:12:01.588 --> 00:12:04.188
in appropriate forms, and maybe not for the appropriate reasons.

00:12:04.968 --> 00:12:08.348
So we're going to talk about all of that next year. I'd love for you to join us.

00:12:08.648 --> 00:12:11.888
If you have questions, please reach out to me anytime. I'd love to hear from

00:12:11.888 --> 00:12:14.388
you. Otherwise, I hope you have a lovely rest of your day.